Notion vs Confluence: Will Your Team Use Actually Them?

Notion and Confluence, these tools are in-escapable to hear/work on as a corporate professional.

Notion, the new kid on the block, took the productivity world by storm with its flexible, all-in-one approach. It's like the Swiss Army knife of workspaces – adaptable, multifunctional, and beloved by startups and creatives alike.

Confluence, on the other hand, is the battle-tested veteran. Born from the Atlassian family, it's been the go-to for tech teams and large enterprises for years, offering robust documentation and seamless integration with other Atlassian tools.

If you're scratching your head trying to decide between these two, you're not alone. Both tools boast impressive features and loyal user bases, but they each shine in their own unique ways.

But here's the thing – your perfect tool depends on your team's specific needs, workflows, and pain points. Are you looking for ultimate flexibility or rock-solid reliability? Do you need a jack-of-all-trades or a master of documentation?

In this deep dive, we'll pit Notion against Confluence in a head-to-head comparison across 12 most important criteria, and who’s the clear winner in each.

Confluence vs Notion: Comparing Ease of Use

Notion prides itself on being intuitive right out of the gate. It is:

• Clean, minimalist interface that’s easy on the eyes
• Drag-and-drop functionality for effortless page organization
• Flexible structure allows you to build your workspace your way

But here’s the catch – Notion’s flexibility can be a double-edged sword. With great power comes… well, a bit of a learning curve. Some users find themselves asking, “Wait, what can’t this thing do?” Be prepared for a steep learning curve due to its powerful feature set.

Confluence, on the other hand, is like that reliable old desktop computer – it might not be the sleekest, but it gets the job done with:

• Structured interface with clear hierarchies
• Familiar layout for those used to traditional document management
• Powerful features readily available, but can clutter the interface

The trade-off? Confluence’s learning curve can be steeper, especially for non-technical users. It’s packed with features, which is great once you know your way around, but can be daunting at first glance.

Winner - Notion

If you're after a tool that you can dive into immediately and shape to your needs, Notion's your go-to. It's perfect for teams that value flexibility and don't mind a bit of DIY.

But if your team prefers a more structured approach and doesn't mind a learning phase for the sake of robust features, Confluence might be your best bet. It's particularly suited for teams already familiar with Atlassian products.

Remember, ease of use is subjective. What's intuitive for a tech-savvy startup might be confusing for a traditional corporate team. Consider your team's technical comfort level when making your choice.

Next up, we'll dive into the nitty-gritty of pricing.

Pricing

Let’s talk money. After all, your budget can make or break your decision, no matter how shiny the features are.

Notion’s pricing is straightforward:

• Free Plan: Great for personal use or small teams (up to 10 guests)
• Plus: $12/month
• Business: $18/user/month
• Enterprise: Custom pricing

The kicker? Notion’s AI is an extra paid add-on for $8/user/month. Which means for hyper-growth teams, Notion costs can add up quickly. When comparing notion pricing with Confluence, it's clear that Notion offers a range of plans that can suit different needs, but the additional costs can be a factor.

Confluence is free for up to 10 users and then charged at $8.15/user monthly. They’re competitively priced. Confluence’s pricing becomes more attractive as you scale up. 

The more seats you need, the better the deal gets. Confluence pricing is particularly cost-effective for larger teams compared to Notion.

The catch? The free tier is limited, and you might need to upgrade sooner than you’d like for certain features.

Winner - Notion

For small to medium-sized teams or those just dipping their toes into collaborative workspaces, Notion's pricing structure offers more flexibility and features at a lower entry point.

Confluence, while potentially pricier for smaller teams, can be more cost-effective for larger organizations, especially those already invested in the Atlassian ecosystem.

Remember, the true cost isn't just the sticker price. Consider the time saved (or spent) on setup, training, and maintenance. A cheaper tool that no one uses is no bargain at all.

Features

Now, let’s roll up our sleeves and dig into the meat and potatoes of both platforms. What can these tools actually do for you?

Notion is the jack of all trades, master of… well, quite a few actually.

• Databases: From simple tables to complex relational databases
• Kanban boards: Visual task management at its finest
• Wikis: Build your company’s brain, one page at a time
• Notes: From quick jots to full-fledged documents
• Project management: Track progress, assign tasks, set deadlines

Manage projects: Organize, customize, and collaborate on various project-related tasks and documentation

But here’s the rub - Notion’s “everything everywhere all at once” approach can lead to feature overlap. Sometimes you might find yourself wondering, “Wait, should this be a database or a page?”

On the other hand, Confluence knows what it is - a documentation powerhouse. It’s like that friend who’s an expert in their field and doesn’t try to be anything else.

Robust document editing: Version history, collaborative editing, and more

Structured spaces and pages: Organize information with clear hierarchies

Macros: Add dynamic content to your pages (like JIRA issues or roadmaps)

Powerful search: Find what you need, fast

Templates: Jump-start your work with pre-built page structures

Document collaboration: Seamless integration with essential software tools like Jira, and cost-effective pricing

Confluence shines when it comes to creating and organizing documentation. It’s the go-to for software teams, technical writers, and anyone who needs to manage complex information.

Winner - Notion

If you're after a flexible tool that can adapt to a variety of use cases - from note-taking to project management to database - Notion is your Swiss Army knife.

But if your primary need is robust documentation with deep integration into the Atlassian ecosystem, Confluence is the specialized tool you're looking for.

Integrations

We want our apps to talk to each other. We all about how well a tool integrates with your existing tech stack can make or break its usefulness.

Notion offers:

• 250+ integrations through Zapier
• Native integrations with popular tools like Slack, Google Drive, and Trello
• API for custom integrations (though it's relatively new)

Notion's strength lies in its flexibility. You can embed content from various sources directly into your pages, creating a centralized hub for all your work.

Confluence boasts:

• Deep integration with other Atlassian products (Jira, Trello, Bitbucket)
• 3000+ apps and integrations in the Atlassian Marketplace
• Robust API for custom integrations

Confluence's integration with the Atlassian suite is unparalleled, making it a powerhouse for teams already using these tools.

Winner - Confluence

While Notion offers a good range of integrations, Confluence takes the cake here. Its extensive Marketplace and seamless integration with the Atlassian ecosystem give it a clear edge, especially for tech-oriented teams.

Templates

Templates can be a game-changer, helping teams standardize processes and saving time on setup. Let's see how our contenders stack up.

Notion has a great in-house and external template support. Confluence's templates are more structured and often come with helpful macros pre-installed. They're particularly strong for software development and IT operations. 

Winner - Tie

This one's too close to call. Both platforms offer great templates. Notion's templates tend to be more flexible and customizable, while Confluence's are often more specialized and feature-rich out of the box.

Your choice here might depend on your specific use case. If you need highly customizable templates for varied purposes, Notion might edge ahead. For more standardized, industry-specific templates (especially in tech), Confluence could be your best bet.

Document Collaboration

Notion shines with:

• Real-time collaboration on all content
• Comments and @mentions
• Sharing options for both internal and external collaborators
• Activity feed to track changes

These features make Notion one of the leading collaboration tools for efficient teamwork and project management.

Confluence offers:

• Real-time editing with visual indicators of who’s working where
• Inline, page, and file comments
• @mentions and tasks
• Detailed page history and version control

Confluence’s collaboration features are deeply integrated with its documentation focus, making it excellent for cooperative writing and reviewing.

Winner - Confluence

While both tools offer strong collaboration features, Confluence takes the lead with its more robust version control and detailed page history. These features are crucial for large teams working on complex documents.

The best choice depends on your team's collaboration style. If you need tight control over document versions and edits, Confluence is your best bet. For more fluid, multifaceted collaboration, Notion might be the way to go.

Search functionality

Notion offers quick search across all workspaces, with the ability to search within specific pages or databases. Its search is fast and covers all content types, but can sometimes struggle with partial matches or complex queries.

Confluence provides powerful full-text search with advanced operators (AND, OR, NOT), the ability to search by author, date, and content type, and search macros for embedding dynamic search results in pages. Its search is more robust, especially when dealing with large amounts of structured content.

Winner - Confluence

Confluence takes the crown here with its more advanced search capabilities. However, Notion's search works well for most use cases, especially for smaller teams or individuals. Consider the volume and complexity of your content when making your choice.

Customization and Flexibility

Notion excels with its highly flexible page structure, custom databases and views, customizable templates and workflows, and a no-code approach to building workspaces. Its strength lies in its adaptability - you can build almost anything, from a simple note-taking system to a complex project management tool.

Confluence offers customizable spaces and page hierarchies, custom templates, an extensive macro system for adding dynamic content, and integration with other Atlassian tools for custom workflows. Its customization is more structured but powerful, especially when combined with other Atlassian products.

Winner - Notion

Notion takes the lead here with its unparalleled flexibility. However, your choice depends on your need for structure versus flexibility. If you want a tool you can mold to fit any process, Notion is your best bet. If you prefer a more structured system with powerful customization within that structure, Confluence might be the way to go.

Mobile Experience: On-the-Go Productivity

Notion's mobile app offers a clean, intuitive interface that closely mirrors the desktop experience. Most features are available on mobile, including real-time collaboration and database management. However, some users report occasional syncing issues and slower performance with complex pages.

Confluence's mobile app provides access to spaces, pages, and basic editing functions. While it offers a solid viewing experience, advanced editing and some macros are limited on mobile. The app integrates well with other Atlassian mobile tools.

Winner - Notion

Notion edges out with a friendlier mobile experience, offering closer feature parity with its desktop version. However, if your mobile needs are primarily for viewing and basic edits, both options are viable.

Security and Compliance

Notion employs end-to-end encryption for data in transit and at rest, offers granular access controls, and complies with GDPR and SOC 2 Type 2. However, it lacks some advanced enterprise security features and isn't HIPAA compliant.

Confluence provides robust security measures including encryption, detailed access controls, and audit logs. It offers compliance with GDPR, SOC 2, ISO 27001, and can be configured for HIPAA compliance. As part of the Atlassian suite, it benefits from enterprise-grade security infrastructure.

Winner - Confluence

Confluence takes the lead here with its more  security features and compliance certifications, making it a better choice for enterprises with strict security requirements.

Scalability

Notion handles large amounts of data well, with some users reporting smooth operation with thousands of pages. It scales easily for growing teams, with no hard limits on users or content. However, very large databases or complex pages can sometimes experience performance issues.

Confluence is built to handle enterprise-scale operations, easily managing large volumes of content and users. It maintains performance as teams grow, thanks to Atlassian’s robust infrastructure. However, the increasing complexity of permissions and structure can become challenging to manage at scale. Confluence is particularly well-suited for larger teams and complex projects due to its advanced collaboration capabilities.

Winner - Confluence

While both tools scale well, Confluence's enterprise-ready infrastructure gives it an edge for large organizations. However, Notion's scalability is more than sufficient for most small to medium-sized teams.

Knowledge Management

Notion excels in flexible knowledge organization with its hierarchical page structure and powerful database features. It allows for easy linking between pages and databases, creating a web of interconnected information. The ability to combine different content types on a single page enhances information context.

Confluence offers a structured approach to knowledge management with spaces, hierarchical pages, and powerful search. Its strength lies in creating interconnected documentation and supporting extensive knowledge bases. Features like page trees and space overviews provide clear information architecture. Additionally, Confluence excels in large-scale knowledge sharing, making it suitable for enterprise organizations.

Winner - Tie

This one's too close to call. Notion offers more flexibility in organizing information, while Confluence provides a more structured approach. Your choice depends on whether you prefer a more freeform or hierarchical organization of knowledge.

Enterprise Features

Notion offers Single Sign-On (SSO) integration with popular identity providers, basic user provisioning through SCIM, and a tiered permissions system. It allows for creating custom roles and setting page-level permissions. However, some users find the enterprise features less robust compared to more established platforms.

Confluence provides great enterprise features including advanced SSO options, detailed user provisioning and deprovisioning, and granular permissions at the space, page, and even paragraph level. It offers SAML 2.0 support, integrates with enterprise identity management systems, and provides advanced audit logs.

Winner - Confluence

Confluence takes the lead here with its more mature enterprise features. Its deep integration with enterprise systems and granular control options make it a better fit for large organizations with complex security and management needs.

However, Notion's enterprise offerings are continually improving and may be sufficient for many businesses

The Final Verdict: Learning Curve

After our deep dive into Notion and Confluence, it’s clear that both tools have their strengths. But which one is right for you? Let’s break it down:

Choose Notion if:

• You value flexibility and customization above all
• Your team needs an all-in-one tool for notes, tasks, and databases
• You’re a smaller team or startup looking for an intuitive, adaptable solution
• You prefer a modern, minimalist interface

Go with Confluence if:

• Your primary focus is robust documentation and knowledge management
• You’re already invested in the Atlassian ecosystem
• You’re a larger enterprise with complex security and compliance needs
• You require advanced version control and structured content organization

In summary, both Confluence and Notion offer unique advantages depending on your specific needs and organizational context.

Alternatives to Confluence and Notion

While Notion and Confluence are heavyweight contenders in the collaboration space, they’re not the only players in the game. These platforms also integrate seamlessly with other tools, making them versatile options for various use cases. Let’s explore some alternatives, with a special focus on a rising star: Slite.

Slite

Slite is gaining traction as a compelling alternative that strikes a balance between Notion’s flexibility and Confluence’s structure.

Here’s why it’s worth considering:

• Intuitive Interface: Slite offers a clean, user-friendly design that’s easy to navigate, reducing the learning curve for new users.
• Structured Flexibility: It provides a more guided experience than Notion, with pre-defined content types, while still offering customization options.
• Focus on Documentation: Like Confluence, Slite excels in creating and organizing documentation, but with a more modern approach.
• Collaborative Features: Real-time editing, comments, and @mentions make teamwork seamless.
• Integrated with Workflows: Slite integrates task management and decision-making tools directly into your documentation.
• AI Search: Ask natural questions and get verified answers from your docs anywhere

What sets Slite apart is its focus on balancing structure and flexibility. It provides enough guardrails to keep your team organized, but enough freedom to adapt to various use cases. This makes it particularly appealing for teams that find Notion too open-ended and Confluence too rigid. With Slite, you can explore limitless possibilities for organizing and managing your team's documentation and workflows.

Other Alternatives

• Coda: Another all-in-one doc that blends documents, spreadsheets, and applications.
• GitBook: Great for technical documentation and API docs.
• Slab: Focuses on internal knowledge bases with a clean, minimalist interface.

‍